Why Can People with Tourette’s Suppress Their Tics Only Sometimes?
One of the biggest misconceptions surrounding Tourette’s syndrome is the illusion of control. Those unfamiliar with the condition may see someone with Tourette’s go an hour, a morning or even a whole day with very few visible tics, only to see their tics become much more noticeable at another time. The conclusion follows almost automatically: ‘If you managed it before, it means you can do it all the time.’ Nothing could be further from the truth.
Many people with Tourette’s are able to temporarily suppress certain tics, but this does not mean they can freely decide when to have them and when to stop them. The ability to suppress tics varies enormously from person to person, from tic to tic, and even over the course of the same day. Confusing temporary control with willpower means looking only at the outward result, whilst completely ignoring the effort that may lie behind it.
Suppressing a tic does not mean you do not have Tourette’s
Voluntary suppression of tics is possible for many people, at least for short periods. It can be similar to trying not to sneeze, scratch or blink. You may manage it for a while, especially if you have a strong reason to do so, but this does not mean that the urge has disappeared. Many people with Tourette’s experience a premonitory urge before a tic: a feeling of pressure, discomfort, tension, or the sense that something is not quite right until the movement or sound is made.
Suppressing a tic can therefore mean living with that sensation whilst simultaneously trying to carry on talking, working or following a lesson. Not everyone experiences these premonitory sensations in the same way, and not everyone is able to recognise them before every tic. The ability to resist also varies: some people manage to do so for several minutes, others for just a few seconds, and others hardly at all. The fact that a person manages to do so on one occasion does not mean they can repeat the same result every time.
What happens whilst a person is suppressing their tics
From the outside, it may seem as though nothing is happening. Inside, however, the person may be focused on the urge to tic, on their own body and on the reactions of those around them.
‘Is it coming?’
‘Can I stop it?’
‘Will anyone notice?’
‘How much longer until I can leave?’
Many people describe suppression as tiring, frustrating and requiring concentration. In a study based on patients’ first-hand accounts, over 90 per cent reported feeling discomfort or a sense of incompleteness whilst suppressing their tics. This does not mean that their memory automatically fails or that they are unable to carry out other tasks. It does, however, mean that part of their attention may be focused on controlling their body rather than on the conversation, the lesson or their work. This is why a person may appear perfectly calm and, at the same time, struggle enormously to follow everything that is being said to them. Outward calm is not always synonymous with inner calm.
Why tics can become more noticeable upon returning home
Many families describe the same situation: at school or at work, tics seem almost absent, whilst at home they become much more evident. The most obvious explanation is the ‘rebound effect’, as if all the tics held back during the day were set to come out all at once the moment the door is opened. This image is intuitive, but it has not been confirmed as a general rule. In experimental studies, suppression did not automatically lead to an increase in tics above normal levels once the effort ceased. At home, something much simpler may be happening: the person stops holding back.
Out and about, they fear being watched, mocked, told off or seen as unprofessional. Within the home, they may feel secure enough to let the tics come out without having to constantly monitor every movement. The tics therefore become more visible not necessarily because they have built up, but because the effort required to hide them is no longer needed. This is not an act of defiance towards the family, nor does it mean that the person was faking their Tourette’s outside the home. It may mean that, when out, the person was wearing a ‘suit of armour’ and that home is the place where they can finally take it off.
The role of tiredness, stress and concentration
The ability to suppress tics does not remain constant at all times. After a tough day, during a stressful period or when they are tired, it can become much harder to devote further energy to controlling one’s body. In certain particularly engaging activities, however, a person may notice that their tics diminish. This can happen whilst playing an instrument, drawing, working on a computer, playing sport or being completely absorbed in something they love.
But this is not a universal switch. The very activity that reduces tics in one person may increase them in another due to excitement, tiredness or the pressure to perform well. Studies also show that the relationship between attention and tics is complex: directing one’s attention away from tics can sometimes reduce them, but in other circumstances, distraction can make it harder to control them. That is why it makes no sense to say: ‘You don’t have tics when you’re playing, so you could control them in the same way at school.’ Playing, sitting a test and taking part in a meeting do not require the same kind of concentration and do not cause the same level of tension. Above all, having fewer tics during an activity does not mean that Tourette’s has temporarily disappeared.
How to behave without constantly asking them to control themselves
Telling someone with Tourette’s to stay still can make them realise one very simple thing: that their body is causing a disturbance. From that moment on, they are no longer just a participant in the situation. They also have to control themselves, observe others’ reactions and worry about when the next tic will occur.
There is no need to comment on every movement or constantly ask:
‘Can’t you stop it?’
‘You didn’t do that before.’
‘Can you try for at least a few minutes?’
When tics do not pose a danger, it is often best to carry on as normal without making them the centre of attention. This does not guarantee that they will diminish, but it avoids adding further pressure and embarrassment. Of course, there are also behavioural therapies, such as the Comprehensive Behavioral Intervention for Tics (CBIT), which teach specific strategies for managing certain tics. However, these are not the same as simply telling someone to hold back: they require structured techniques and do not prove that the person could control themselves at any time if only they tried hard enough. The fact that someone with Tourette’s manages to stay still for an hour does not tell you how much effort it cost them. It merely shows that, for that hour, they managed not to let you see it.
If you found this article interesting, you may also like this!







